- Jack Welsh: December 7, 1970 – December 5, 1980
- Ronald Crane: December 6, 1980 – December 14, 1982
- Ebenezer Paikai: June 27, 1983 – Dec 18, 1985
- From December 15, 1982, thru June 26, 1983, the police department was operated administratively by Sergeant Thomas Nicholson and Detective Sergeant John Sprague. Police Chief, Ebenezer Paikai, began his tenure on June 27, 1983. Paikai later resigned his post in December of 1985 to accept a similar position with the City of Greenacres Department of Public Safety on December 19, 1985.
- Raymond Funk: Dec 19, 1985 – June 4, 1991
- Re-assigned to the rank of Fire Lieutenant on December 14, 1982. He remained in that position until he resigned on August 7, 1987. Ron Crane served the town for over ten (10) years in the Public Safety Department and almost another decade of service with the Town's Volunteer Fire Department previous to that.
- Joseph Vondembowski: June 5, 1991 – December 31st, 2002
- Rodney Thomas: February 4, 2003 – January 31, 2007
- From January 1, 2003, thru February 3rd, 2003, the police department was operated administratively by Lieutenant Thomas Nicholson until the promotion of Rodney Thomas on February 4, 2003, from the rank of Sergeant. On February 1, 2007, the town contracted law enforcement services with the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office, and Chief Thomas was given the rank of Lieutenant with the PBSO assigned to the town sub-station, District-II..
